Close this search box.

Apple Watch most accurate wrist wearable for measuring heartbeat

Apple Watch is the most accurate wrist worn consumer wearable when it comes to measuring someone’s heartbeat. On average the accuracy of the Apple Watch was 90 percent, while other wearables (Fitbit Charge HR, Mio Alpha and Basis Peak) didn’t score higher than the low 80’s. This is the result of a test in the Cleveland Clinic.

Researchers at Cleveland Clinic wanted to test how well the four popular wearable devices measured heart rate, which is involved in a formula that calculate how many calories a person is burning while they exercise. The research was published in JAMA Cardiology

During the tests 50 healthy adults were hooked up to an electrocardiogram (EKG), the gold-standard test for measuring heart activity. The researchers measured everyone at rest, then walking and jogging on a treadmill. The results obtained by Fitbit Charge HR, Apple Watch, Mio Alpha and Basis Peak were compared, while the researchers also assessed a chest strap.

Chest strap most accurate

The chest strap monitor was the most accurate, nearly matching the EKG with 99% accuracy—both technologies capture electrical activity coming from the heart. Of the wrist wearables, Apple Watch had about a 90 percent accuracy. The other ones dropped off into the low 80s for their accuracy, says Dr. Gordon Blackburn, one of the study’s authors and director of cardiac rehabilitation at Cleveland Clinic.
Accuracy also went down as intensity increased. Blackburn states: “What we really noticed was all of the devices did not a bad job at rest for being accurate for their heart rate, but as the activity intensity went up, we saw more and more variability. At the higher levels of activity, some of the wrist technology was not accurate at all.”

Disadvantages wrist measurements

Measuring heart rate from the wrist is convenient, but it comes with some disadvantages. All of the wrist technologies are looking at blood flow. Good contact between the photosensing cells is necessary. As a person is exercising more vigorously, there’s more bounce, so the devices may lose some of that contact.

In short, when someone needs to measure their heartbeat because of a medical condition, it’s better not to use a wrist worn wearable but a chest strap. Wearable trackers are not intended to be medical devices. Apple is said to be working on improving accuracy and features for the Apple Watch and SDK’s like HealthKit.

Fitbit contests low accuracy

In response to the research, Fitbit stated: “Unlike chest straps, wrist-based trackers fit comfortably into everyday life, providing continuous heart rate for up to several days without recharging (vs. a couple hours at a time) to give a much more informative picture of overall health and fitness trends.” Internal tests showed an accuracy rate of 94 percent. Fitbit also recently launched the FitBit Research Library, containing validated research using Fitbit devices for health related research.


ICT&health World Conference 2024

Experience the future of healthcare at the ICT&health World Conference from May 14th to 16th, 2024!
Secure your ticket now and immerse yourself in groundbreaking technologies and innovative solutions.
Engage with fellow experts and explore the power of global collaborations.

Share this article!

Read also
Navigating Digital Maturity in Healthcare IT
Digital maturity vs. Reality. How to rethink the IT staff role in a hospital
Online health care icon application on smart phone
End-users of mobile health apps expect far more than a good design
Mayo Clinic started with its innovations for its ten million patients and demonstrated that its model worked, and that data could be ethically and responsibly used to drive innovations.
John Halamka: 'Create the Fear of Missing Out'
Balancing regulatory compliance with seamless adoption, healthcare navigates the integration of AI solutions.
A guide to implementing AI in healthcare amid the EU AI Act
Futurist Amy Webb claims that wearables will evolve into "connectables"
Digital health solutions empower patients to better manage their health and integrate care into their daily lives.
How to improve Digital Patient Engagement to streamline workflows
For people with diabetes, inaccurate blood glucose measurements can lead to errors in diabetes management, including taking the wrong dose of insulin, sulfonylureas, or other medications that can rapidly lower blood glucose.
Smartwatches measuring glucose level: Harmful but easy to buy fake innovations
How to introduce innovation and AI in healthcare organizations if there is no business model for prevention and quality – Our interview with Professor Ran Balicer, the Chief Innovation Officer at Clalit Health Services and founding Director of Clalit Research Institute.
I see no legitimate rationale for delaying the digital transformation in healthcare
Pioneering Cardiac Arrest Detection for Enhanced Survival.
CardioWatch Revolutionizes Cardiac Arrest Detection
Dr. Oscar Díaz-Cambronero, Head of Perioperative Medicine Department at La Fe Hospital, spearheads innovative telemonitoring initiatives revolutionizing patient care
Smartwatches Saving Lives Inside and Outside the Hospital
Follow us